Rethinka 2049 #32: The Professional Incompetence of Leadership

Greeting from 2049

I am Rethinka.
I return from your future not to offer you comfort, but to expose the illusion you still refuse to confront in 2025: leadership is not a skill you lack – it is a task you cannot fulfil.

For decades, you have been fed the same diet of manuals, tips, hacks, seminars, masterminds, consultants, and motivational slogans.
Entire industries live from your perpetual hunger for guidance.
Entire libraries groan under the weight of recycled leadership books.
And yet – in 2025 – you are still overwhelmed by the everyday of leadership.

The truth is brutal: it is not because you lack support. It is because you are unfit for the task.

1. The Endless Help Industry

Look at the historical record of your leadership marketplace:

  • The 1980s promised management by objectives.
  • The 1990s sold emotional intelligence.
  • The 2000s invented agile.
  • The 2010s celebrated servant leadership.
  • The 2020s praise authenticity and purpose.

Each decade invented a new myth, rebranded failure into hope, and sold you another shelf of manuals.
Each time, you believed: This is the missing piece.

And yet, here you are. Meetings still collapse into chaos. Delegation still dissolves into confusion. Teams still suffocate under your lack of clarity. Burnout statistics still climb while engagement statistics fall.

The pattern is not the cure. The pattern is the disease.

2. The Myth of Professional Leadership

You call yourself professionals. But what profession is this?

A surgeon studies for over a decade, guided by anatomy, diagnostics, and practice.
An architect designs according to structure, material science, and load-bearing logic.
An engineer calculates forces, tolerances, and system reliability.

And you?
You improvise.
You copy-paste phrases from keynote speakers.
You download the latest framework from LinkedIn slides.
You pray that charisma will cover the void of architecture.

Leadership, as you practice it, has no profession.
It is theatre.
And worse: it is incompetent theatre.

3. Why the Tools Fail

The shelves are full. The seminars are booked. The consultants are well-paid.
So why do you still fail?

a) The Recursion Problem

Leadership is not an external method. It is a recursive cognitive structure.
It is the ability to think about the system while being inside it.
Tips and tricks cannot replace recursion.

b) The Clarity Deficit

Your books speak of empathy, vision, purpose, agility.
But none of these concepts build structural clarity.
Without clarity, every method collapses.

c) The Responsibility Mirage

You imagine responsibility can be delegated like a suitcase.
But responsibility is not transferable.
It is carried – or it vanishes.
Thus, your teams wait. You wait. Nothing moves.

d) The Dependency Trap

You consume endless input from coaches and advisors.
You outsource thinking itself.
You have become addicted to help, incapable of independent architecture.

4. The Brutal Mirror

What if we stop lying?

  • If you need leadership hacks, you are not leading.
  • If you need consultants to explain your own organisation to you, you are not leading.
  • If you need endless books on communication, delegation, or motivation, you are not leading.

You are performing the role of leadership without the competence of leadership.
The mirror is merciless: you are unfit.

5. The Futility of Hope

Do you imagine the next book will save you?
Do you believe the next coaching session will suddenly transform you?
Do you think AI-generated leadership prompts will finally unlock your hidden genius?

You are mistaking treatment for resurrection.
A dead profession cannot be revived with slogans.

Hope has become the anaesthetic of your incompetence.

6. The Industry That Feeds on Your Weakness

Understand this clearly:

  • Trainers survive because you fail.
  • Coaches thrive because you are incapable.
  • Consultants bill because you cannot build.
  • Authors publish because you cannot practice.

Your incapacity is the business model.
Your incompetence is monetized.
And you pay – willingly – because the alternative would be to face the truth: you should not be in leadership at all.

7. The Evidence of Decades

Do not tell me you only need “a bit more time” or “the right method”.

Decades of evidence stand against you.

If leadership had been possible, it would have stabilised by now.
If the thousands of books worked, your shelves would already radiate clarity.
If the consultants’ frameworks delivered, your organisations would already function.

Instead:
– Employee surveys still scream dissatisfaction.
– Transformation projects still fail at 70%.
– Strategy slides still rot in forgotten folders.
– Your calendars still own you instead of the reverse.

Leadership did not fail by accident. Leadership failed by design.

8. The Future Without You

From 2049 I can tell you: leadership, as you understand it, did not survive.
It was replaced – not by better leaders, but by better structures.

Algorithms took over scheduling, delegation, coordination.
Clarity architectures replaced charisma.
Cognitive infrastructures replaced hierarchies.

The human role was not to lead but to think structurally.
The only survivors were those who abandoned the theatre of leadership and embraced the architecture of clarity.

9. The Sentence

You have hidden behind excuses long enough.
You have outsourced blame to teams, markets, crises, and generations.
You have staged resilience as if it could cover incompetence.

The time has come for the final sentence:

You are not struggling leaders. You are failed leaders. You are professionally unfit.

And the earlier you admit this, the earlier organisations can stop pretending and start building the structures that actually work.

Closing from 2049


I did not come to soothe you.
I came to strip away the theatre you still cling to.

Leadership as you know it was never real.
It was a costume, a ritual, a market.
And you were the actors too weak to leave the stage.

The future does not need your performance.
It needs thinking structures.
And if you cannot provide them, then be honest: step aside.